$405K less! Grab this chance! The C.E. Morris Mansion with eight fireplaces! Circa 1800 in Ohio.

Step back into the gilded age of Columbus history with a residence that balances dramatic presence with complete urban privacy. Built in the late 1800s, the historic C.E. Morris Mansion is a beautifully preserved Romanesque Revival estate commanding a premier position on East Broad Street. It offers an incredible blend of structural scale, timeless Queen Anne architectural details, and modern, high-end preservation. Whether you are looking for an unparalleled private family compound or a historic estate with immense social presence, this architectural marvel offers a rare chance to own a registered piece of Ohio’s cultural legacy.

Address: 875 E Broad St, Columbus, OH 43205

Price: $1,895,000

Total Square Footage: 6,649 sqft

The Exterior & Curb Appeal

The mansion delivers an unforgettable first impression, balancing the heavy, grounding masonry of Romanesque Revival architecture with the whimsical asymmetry of the Queen Anne movement. The facade is a masterclass in craftsmanship, boasting intricate terracotta carvings, towering stepped chimneys, and a prominent corner turret that catches the natural daylight. Setting this home entirely apart from its peers are the beautifully integrated historic architectural elements reclaimed from the former Indianola United Methodist Church, offering a deep sense of local history woven directly into the masonry.

Striking Romanesque Revival & Queen Anne Style: Bold irregular massing, eye-catching corner turret, and distinctive tall stepped chimneys.
Rich Stone Detailing: Textured masonry enhanced by cut stone lintels, sills, column capitals, brackets, and meticulously carved pilaster bases.
Historic Reclaimed Elements: Incorporated architectural pieces saved from the historic Indianola United Methodist Church.
Official Historic Registry Status: Formally listed on the National Register of Historic Places (1986) and the Columbus Register of Historic Properties (1988).

Main Entrance & Common Living Spaces

Cross the threshold into a world of grand scale and historic charm. The main level introduces you to massive, light-filled rooms featuring beautiful hardwood floors, custom French doors, and classic transom window openers that permit gentle airflow between spaces. The formal living areas are perfect for staging sophisticated gatherings or establishing distinct formal seating configurations, all anchored by gorgeous decorative gas-log fireplaces.

Grand Formal Living Spaces: Thirteen expansive rooms across a highly flexible floor plan.
Timeless Period Details: Gorgeous custom French doors, transom window openers, and classic trim.
Eight Total Fireplaces: Multiple decorative, gas-log fireplaces serve as architectural focal points.
High-End Flooring: A seamless blend of timeless wood, ceramic porcelain, and durable laminate flooring.

Kitchen & Dining Area

Designed to handle everything from quiet morning coffees to grand catered events, the kitchen and dining zones prioritize flow and utility. The grand formal dining room comfortably accommodates large dinner parties, showcasing an atmosphere built for memorable entertaining. The kitchen space is supported by high-quality modern appliances and a central water purification system, ensuring effortless meal preparation and hosting.

Massive Formal Dining Room: Scaled easily for oversized banquet tables and large-group entertaining.
Complete Appliance Suite: Equipped with a gas range, dishwasher, microwave, refrigerator, and built-in trash compactor.
Utility & Comfort: Includes an owned water purification system and practical, scuff-resistant flooring.
Hosting Ready: Excellent flow connecting the cooking area directly to formal and casual common rooms.

Main Bedrooms & Bathrooms Breakdown

The upper levels provide an expansive retreat with a massive configuration of seven bedrooms and five bathrooms. This layout gives large families or multi-generational households immense personal space, while easily allowing individual rooms to be converted into private media dens, libraries, or nursery spaces.

Seven Generous Bedrooms: Exceptional flexibility for family, overnight guests, or specialized hobby rooms.
Five Total Bathrooms: Configured with two full bathrooms and three convenient half-baths distributed intelligently across the levels.
Spa-Like Amenities: Features integrated whirlpool and garden soaking tubs for optimal relaxation.
Exceptional Closet Storage: Generous closet depths throughout the upper living quarters.

Special & Bonus Levels

The versatility of this estate extends from top to bottom. The mansion features a full, walk-up lower level with its own dedicated exterior entry—making it a prime candidate for an independent in-law suite, a private home business, or an expansive speakeasy-style media room.

Full Walk-Up Basement: Features a convenient separate exterior entry path for excellent accessibility.
Lower-Level Finished Bath: Includes a full bathroom on the lower level to support a recreation room or guest suite.
Handmade Limestone Walls: Striking, historic exposed stone structures adding undeniable character to the lower levels.
Multi-Zone Mechanics: Modern forced air heating and central air conditioning systems ensuring complete temperature control.

Outdoor Space, Parking & Proximity

The exterior grounds feel like a secure urban oasis. Dual electric security gates at the front and back of the property open to a completely private, fenced, and tree-lined perimeter. A long private driveway stretches all the way from East Broad Street through to East Capital Street, while a large stone front porch offers the perfect vantage point to overlook the neighborhood.

Dual Electric Gates: Completely secured, gated entry stretching between East Broad Street and East Capital Street.
Carriage House Ready: Features a solid, pre-poured concrete foundation ready for a new custom garage or carriage house build.
Complete Outdoor Privacy: Enclosed by full fencing and mature, tree-lined boundaries featuring multiple dedicated seating areas and a balcony.
Premier Central Location: Set right in the heart of Olde Towne East, offering rapid, direct access to Downtown Columbus and local highway corridors.

Conclusion

The Historic C.E. Morris Mansion represents a once-in-a-generation real estate opportunity. To find a home with over 6,600 square feet of meticulously preserved 19th-century architecture, paired with a half-acre gated double-lot in one of the city’s most vibrant historic districts, is an absolute rarity. It offers an incredible value proposition for buyers seeking unmatched presence, historical character, and long-term prestige.

Unrivaled Architectural Prestige: Own an official, registered Romanesque Revival landmark piece of Columbus history.
0.58-Acre Secure Compound: Rare double-street lot access with dual electric security gates and a pre-poured garage foundation.
Unmatched Scale & Utility: 6,649 square feet featuring 7 bedrooms, 5 baths, 8 fireplaces, and a separate-entry walk-up lower level.

From Zillow

Price Drop! The Historic C.E. Morris Mansion, built in the late 1800’s, is a beautifully preserved Romanesque Revival estate set along East Broad Street in the Ol Town East district. Rich in architectural character, the home has been carefully restored over time and incorporates select historic elements reclaimed from the former Indianola United Methodist Church on 17th Avenue and Summit. The building displays distinct elements of the Queen Anne style in its irregular massing, corner turret, and tall stepped chimneys. Its textured masonry appearance is enhanced by the use of stone trim, cut stone lintels and sills, and richly carved stone details such as column capitals, brackets, and pilaster bases and capitals.

The property was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1986 and the Columbus Register of Historic Properties in 1988, reflecting its architectural and historical significance. A gated entry leads to a private drive extending from East Broad Street to East Capital Street, offering both privacy and presence. Entry into the property is through electric gates at both the front and back. This mansion is complemented with a large stone front porch, terracotta carvings, a poured foundation for a garage or carriage house, several outdoor seating areas, and a tree-lined yard with fencing for complete privacy. This distinguished residence features thirteen rooms total with seven bedrooms, two full baths, and three half baths, complemented by grand living spaces and timeless details throughout. Highlights include custom French doors, handmade limestone walls, transom window openers, a walk-up lower-level exterior entry, and generous storage.

Photos: