Missed chance! Just wow! Classic craftsmanship! Circa 1929 in New York.

Uncover a rare historic treasure hidden right at the end of a peaceful, private street. Built in 1929, this charming 4-bedroom Colonial is bursting with architectural pedigree and an incredibly unique backstory. Featuring actual materials sourced from an early local firehouse, it serves as a proud testament to classic craftsmanship that simply cannot be replicated today. Tucked into one of the region’s most coveted pockets, it represents a remarkable canvas for anyone looking to infuse a classic estate with their own personal style.

Vital Stats

• Address: 21 Hillsboro Road, Rochester, New York 14610
• Last listed for: $300,000 (Closed)
• Total Square Footage: 2,175 sq. ft.

The Exterior & Curb Appeal

The front facade instantly transports you to a bygone era, exhibiting a stately profile anchored by legendary materials. Most notably, the magnificent slate roof, heavy door components, and distinctive copper gutters were originally part of the historic Brighton Fire Department, built with a matching architectural philosophy. Nestled on a generous half-acre lot at the end of a dead-end street, the exterior offers an immediate sense of absolute quiet and security.

• Features:
  • Set on a deep, scenic 0.50-acre private lot with mature trees
  • Historic slate and tile roof originally built for a local fire department
  • Authentic architectural copper gutter systems and matching downspouts
  • Peaceful, minimal-traffic positioning on a desirable dead-end street
  • Classic stucco construction paired with a paved blacktop driveway

Main Entrance & Common Living Spaces

Cross the threshold to find a spacious interior layout filled with old-world personality, natural wood tones, and stunning cathedral ceilings. The common areas are framed by exquisite leaded glass windows that cast a gorgeous amber glow across the formal rooms. While the home is waiting for your design touch to bring back its true sparkle, the foundational character here is absolutely undeniable.

• Features:
  • Beautiful, original leaded glass windows that retain historic glass panels
  • Grand, light-filled living room featuring high cathedral ceilings
  • Stately formal dining room ideal for festive holiday gatherings
  • Rich, unpainted natural woodwork and classic period door components
  • Two cozy interior fireplaces adding timeless warmth and focus to the living zones

Kitchen & Dining Area

The core of the house combines old-school architectural lines with excellent foundational utility. Featuring a dedicated eat-in kitchen area and a functional central kitchen island, the space is primed to transition into a dream gourmet workstation. Large sliding glass doors open directly to the back patio, making it easy to transition from indoor meal prep to outdoor entertaining.

• Features:
  • Generous eat-in kitchen layout with an integrated central kitchen island
  • Open kitchen-to-family-room combo creating a highly interactive footprint
  • Bright sliding glass doors providing panoramic views of the scenic backyard
  • Unparalleled convenience with an integrated main-floor laundry room
  • Seamless transition to a private rear concrete patio for summer barbecues

Main Bedrooms/Bathrooms Breakdown

With four substantial bedrooms distributed thoughtfully across the two-story layout, the home easily adapts to your family’s needs. The sleeping quarters feature varied classic flooring types, including traditional hardwoods, while the main level houses a full bathroom to offer maximum single-floor accessibility for guests.

• Features:
  • 4 sizeable, bright bedrooms with ample historic closet spaces
  • 2 full bathrooms strategically split across the levels (1 on the main floor)
  • A primary bathroom layout featuring a luxurious jetted tub
  • Warm hardwood flooring and varied ceramic tile accents throughout
  • Large bedroom windows offering elevated views of the backyard greenery

Special/Bonus Levels

The home’s auxiliary footprints offer expansive potential for storage, hobby spaces, or future home equity. A full, poured-concrete basement offers a completely blank slate, while a traditional attic space provides that rare, deep structural storage that modern homes always seem to lack.

• Features:
  • Massive, full poured-concrete basement providing an ultra-dry foundation
  • Dedicated den/home office space isolated from the main traffic zones
  • Spacious attic level offering effortless seasonal storage options
  • Secondary basement laundry hooks to supplement the first-floor setup
  • Equipped with programmable smart thermostats for easy climate management

Outdoor Space, Parking & Attractions

The backyard serves as an absolute nature lover’s paradise, where the soothing sounds of Allen Creek trickle right past your property line. Despite the deep natural seclusion, you are steps from pristine hiking paths and positioned inside one of the most celebrated school systems in New York State.

• Features:
  • 2-car attached garage featuring direct water access hookups
  • Scenic Allen Creek running directly through your own backyard oasis
  • A short, casual stroll to the breathtaking trails and waterfalls at Corbett’s Glen Nature Park
  • Highly coveted placement within the award-winning Pittsford School District
  • Includes a standalone exterior storage shed for lawn machinery and gear

Conclusion

21 Hillsboro Road is an architectural diamond in the rough, seamlessly blending a fascinating local historical lineage with an elite neighborhood pedigree. For the visionary buyer, this estate represents a rare chance to invest sweat equity into a classic 1920s asset, securing a high-value property packed with leaded glass, slate finishes, and creekfront tranquility.

• Features Summary:
  • 2,175 sq. ft. historical Colonial footprint packed with unrepeatable character
  • Priceless firehouse salvage history (Slate roof, copper gutters, and door components)
  • Private 0.50-acre dead-end lot featuring Allen Creek right in the backyard
  • Highly prized Pittsford School District zoning with elite local resale values
  • Incredible investment and customization potential, last listed at $300,000

Photos: