Lost chance! Love the exterior! Classic Greek Revival style! Circa 1825 in New York State.

Ever looked at a grand, weathered historic home and felt an immediate pull to bring it back to its former glory? That is exactly the energy radiating from this 1825 Greek Revival brick estate in Pavilion, NY. Offering an incredible footprint and massive acreage, this property is a true time capsule waiting for a visionary to breathe new life into its historic bones.

Address: 11139 S Lake Rd, Pavilion, NY 14525
Price: Last listed for $139,900 (Off Market)
Total Square Footage: 3,166 sqft

The Exterior & Curb Appeal

The property instantly commands attention with its striking, solid brick construction and stately Greek Revival proportions. Rising two stories above a sprawling lot, the home delivers a powerful visual presence that balances historic elegance with high-visibility potential.

Features

Classic Greek Revival Design: Features the timeless, balanced symmetry and strong architectural framing iconic to the early 1800s.
Solid Brick Construction: Built to stand the test of time with a remarkably sturdy, heavy-brick exterior foundation.
Stately Proportions: High-pitched rooflines and grand window placements offer an imposing, proud stance from the roadside.

Main Entrance & Common Living Spaces

Stepping across the threshold feels like turning the pages of a local history book. The main floor opens up into incredibly spacious, grandly proportioned common areas defined by soaring ceilings that make the entire layout feel airy and full of promise.

Features

Soaring Tall Ceilings: High-volume vertical space adds an immediate sense of grandeur and openness to the main living areas.
Wide-Plank Flooring: Features beautiful, original wide-plank wood floors underfoot, rich with decades of character.
Quarter-Sawn Oak Floors: Gorgeous, high-end historic oak flooring patterns grace the main living zones.
Expansive Canvas: Deeply spacious rooms provide a massive, unrestricted layout ready for custom architectural redesign.

Kitchen & Dining Area

While the home requires a complete and total renovation, the dedicated kitchen and dining spaces are positioned beautifully for those who love to host. The scale of the rooms means you aren’t trapped in a cramped layout—there is more than enough footprint here to design a massive chef’s kitchen and an accompanying banquet-sized dining room.

Features

Generous Scale: Massive footprint allows for a seamless transition between a high-utility kitchen and a formal dining area.
Excellent Hosting Flow: Directly connected to the main living spaces, keeping your future guests close to the action.
Historic Character: Ready to blend original structural elements with modern, high-end appliances and cabinetry.

Main Bedrooms & Bathrooms

Heading upstairs, the residence offers a total of four bedrooms and one and a half bathrooms. The bedroom layouts echo the generous proportions of the lower level, ensuring that everyone in the household gets a bedroom with actual breathing room and great views of the surrounding land.

Features

4 Massive Bedrooms: Every bedroom offers ample square footage, avoiding the tiny closet-like spaces found in many modern builds.
1.5 Bathroom Layout: Strategically placed bathrooms provide a solid structural plumbing footprint to expand upon.
Historic Windows: Large bedroom windows look out across the private acreage, pulling in beautiful natural morning light.

Special & Bonus Levels

The versatility of this property extends far beyond a standard single-family home layout. Because of its prime, high-traffic location and dual-story layout, the home easily adapts into a hybrid space—giving you the ultimate opportunity to blend a private residence with a unique professional venture.

Features

Flexible Setup: Ideal configuration for a standout historic residence, a profitable luxury flip, or an upscale in-home business.
Commercial Potential: Stately presence and high-visibility location make it an incredible spot for a small business or office (with local approvals).
Two-Story Versatility: Keep the lower level public-facing for work while preserving the entire upper level for absolute private living.

Outdoor Space & Local Proximity

Set against a picturesque backdrop of 6.8 sprawling acres, the land perfectly balances open, sunlit lawns with dense, mature wooded areas. Located on South Lake Road, the estate offers prime visibility for a business venture while providing plenty of deep acreage to escape into nature.

Features

6.8 Sprawling Acres: A massive blend of cleared, open green spaces and dense, enchanting woodlands.
Clean Slate Outdoor Footprint: The old barn is slated for removal, creating a perfect blank canvas for a new custom carriage house, detached garage, or workshop.
Endless Landscaping Potential: Perfectly suited for massive private gardens, outdoor entertainment decks, or walking trails.
Prime Pavilion Location: Offers easy, direct access to regional routes, making commuting a breeze while keeping local lakes and parks close by.

Conclusion

Though it is no longer on the market, 11139 S Lake Road remains a brilliant example of early American architecture waiting for its second act. For the buyer with a bit of imagination and a love for history, this estate represented the ultimate puzzle—a property with fantastic bones, massive acreage, and the unbeatable charm of the 1800s.

Key Selling Points

Authentic 1825 Heritage: A rare opportunity to preserve and own a registered piece of local Greek Revival history.
Massive 6.8-Acre Lot: Exceptional acreage that provides an unparalleled level of privacy and outdoor freedom.
Incredible Footprint Value: Over 3,100 square feet of robust brick architecture priced significantly below modern reproduction costs.

From Zillow

ATTENTION HISTORIC LOVERS, FLIPPERS, AND ENTREPRENEURS—BRING YOUR VISION TO LIFE! Incredible opportunity to restore a true piece of local history with this c.1825 Greek Revival brick estate in Pavilion, NY! Offering a massive 3,166 sqft of living space, this grand 4-BR, 1.5-BA home boasts rock-solid brick construction, tall ceilings, and original wide-plank and quarter-sawn oak flooring full of historic character. Needs a full renovation—ideal for a passionate restoration project, a high-upside flip, or an incredible in-home business venue leveraging its high-visibility location. Set on 6.8 picturesque acres of open pastures and quiet woodlands with an open footprint ready for your dream carriage house or workshop. Unbeatable regional convenience: just 15 minutes to Batavia, 40 minutes to downtown Rochester, and an easy drive to the stunning lakes of Western New York. Don’t miss the chance to reimagine a masterpiece—schedule your viewing today!

Photos: