Love every single detail! Known as “Painted Lady”! Circa 1886 in New York State.

Ever wondered what it feels like to step inside a living piece of art? Nestled in the heart of Palmyra Village, 160 Cuyler Street is a breathtaking 1886 Victorian “Painted Lady” that perfectly marries grand historic soul with expansive modern living. Spanning over 5,200 square feet on a rare, near-acre village lot, this architectural masterpiece is packed with jaw-dropping original woodwork, vibrant stained glass, and a wrap-around porch made for lazy summer afternoons.

Vital Stats

Address: 160 Cuyler St, Palmyra, NY 14522
Last listed for: $505,000
Total Square Footage: 5,201 sqft

The Exterior & Curb Appeal

Before you even step inside, this home commands your attention. The vibrant multi-toned exterior celebrating its classic “Painted Lady” heritage gives way to a sprawling wrap-around front porch that defines historic American charm. It sits proudly on a lush, expansive lot that feels like a private park right in the middle of the village.

Classic “Painted Lady” Aesthetic: Vibrant, historically accurate exterior trim work.
Massive Wrap-Around Porch: Perfect for outdoor lounging, morning coffee, or greeting neighbors.
Spacious Village Lot: Just under an acre of beautifully landscaped, mature green space.

Main Entrance & Common Living Spaces

Open the heavy front door and you are greeted by an unforgettable grand foyer, anchored by gleaming, intricate woodwork and a crackling wood-burning fireplace. The main floor flows effortlessly from one stunning room to the next, offering both a formal living room and a cozy family room—each boasting its own unique fireplace—alongside a dream library wrapped in custom bookshelves.

Show-Stopping Foyer: Features master-crafted wood detailing and an original fireplace.
Dual Living Rooms: Distinct family and formal living spaces, both equipped with fireplaces.
Private Library/Office: Outfitted with floor-to-ceiling custom bookshelves and rich historic character.
Artistic Accents: Original stained glass windows and pristine brass fixtures throughout.

Kitchen & Dining Area

Designed with the entertainer in mind, the grand kitchen seamlessly blends vintage textures with commercial utility. Look up to admire the highly detailed tin ceilings while preparing meals on the massive commercial-sized range. Just off the kitchen, a sun-drenched dining area features near floor-to-ceiling windows that flood the space with natural light.

Chef’s Kitchen: Outfitted with a commercial-size range, expansive cabinetry, and tons of counter space.
Historic Finishes: Beautifully preserved, detailed tin ceilings overhead.
Sun-Soaked Dining Room: Framed by soaring windows and an additional cozy fireplace.
Main-Floor Utility: Convenient first-floor laundry room located right off the main hub.

Main Bedrooms & Bathrooms

Ascend the grand staircase to find a peaceful sanctuary on the second level. This floor hosts five incredibly spacious bedrooms, ensuring plenty of room for family, guests, or creative spaces. The primary suite serves as a true retreat, complete with its own private en-suite bathroom, supplemented by an additional full bath and a powder room on the same floor.

Five Substantial Bedrooms: Generous layouts with large windows and original architectural trim.
Primary Suite Retreat: Includes a dedicated, private en-suite bathroom.
Flexible Layout: 2.5 bathrooms spread across the upper level to accommodate heavy morning routines easily.

Special & Bonus Levels

The adventure doesn’t stop on the second floor. A massive, full-span attic sits at the very top of the house, offering an incredible blank canvas. Whether you envision a grand media room, an artist’s loft, a home gym, or a massive kids’ playroom, this bonus level is ready to adapt to your lifestyle.

Full-Span Attic: A massive, open bonus footprint with vaulted ceiling potential.
Storage or Living Expansion: Easily convertible into finished square footage or high-capacity storage.

Outdoor Space, Parking & Proximity

Step out the back door into a fairytale courtyard surrounded by secret-garden style plantings. This property is an absolute dream for hobbyists and car enthusiasts, featuring a two-story, three-car garage, an additional historic barn for projects or events, and a dedicated storage shed. Plus, you’re just minutes from local village boutique shops and dining.

Private Courtyard: A quiet, paved outdoor oasis enveloped by lush gardens.
Two-Story, 3-Car Garage: Massive footprint for vehicles, a workshop, or upper-level storage.
Bonus Multi-Use Barn: Extra covered parking or a rustic venue for dynamic activities and hobbies.
Village Convenience: Walking distance to Palmyra attractions and landmarks.

Conclusion

160 Cuyler Street isn’t just a house; it’s a legacy property. For buyers looking for unmatched square footage, unmistakable historical romance, and an abundance of outbuildings that you simply cannot find in modern builds, this Victorian treasure offers incredible value and a lifestyle like no other.

Over 5,200 Sq Ft: Massive historic footprint at an incredible price per square foot.
Six Unique Fireplaces: Unrivaled character and warmth anchored in almost every major room.
Ultimate Hobbyist Setup: Combined garage, barn, and shed spaces on a near-acre lot.

Photos: