$350,000!! Classic Greek Revival! C. 1911 Former Church in Buffalo, NY.
- Address: 220 North St, Buffalo, NY 14201
- Price: $350,000
- Building Size: 31,576 SF
- Price Per SF: $11.08
- Year Built: 1911
This historic landmark offers an incredible amount of space at an unbeatable price point for the area. It is a rare opportunity to find such a significant residence for sale in the heart of Buffalo.
Architectural Significance
- Architect: Designed by the renowned Solon Spencer Beman.
- Style: Striking Neo-Classical and Greek Revival design.
- Exterior Detail: Six-columned portico with fluted Ionic columns and a grand pediment.
- Roofing: Vibrant red roof tiles contrasted with rough-textured masonry.
- Pop Culture: Recently featured in the Oscar-nominated film Nightmare Alley.
The exterior craftsmanship reflects a bygone era of architectural grandeur and meticulous detail. This unique property for sale stands out as a masterpiece of Greek Revival design on a prominent corner lot.
Interior Highlights
- Grand Entry: Cavernous foyer leading into a massive, pillared hall.
- Flooring: High-end terrazzo flooring throughout the main areas.
- Ceilings: Intricate coffered ceilings and a lit canopy arching across the former sanctuary.
- Windows: Massive 25-foot picture windows providing abundant natural light.
- Stories: Two levels of expansive, versatile space.
The interior volume is breathtaking, highlighted by its historic pillars and original flooring materials. Anyone looking for a unique house for sale will appreciate the artistic potential within these massive, open halls.
Location & Potential
- Walk Score: 93 (Walker’s Paradise)
- Bike Score: 92 (Biker’s Paradise)
- Condition: Being sold in “as-is” condition.
- Usage: Ideal for an investment project or an owner-user specialty conversion.
Situated in a highly walkable neighborhood, the location offers easy access to the best of Buffalo’s urban amenities. It is a perfect choice for those seeking a historic residence for sale with significant redevelopment potential.
From Realtor
Originally built in 1911 and designed by architect Solon Spencer Beman, this notable structure, the Karpeles Manuscript Library, was the former First Church of Christ, Scientist.
The architecture is a striking example of Neo-Classical and Greek Revival design, featuring a six-columned portico, fluted Ionic columns, a classic porch, and a pediment. Its unique asymmetric design perfectly complements the corner lot, and the building was recently featured in the film Nightmare Alley.
The interior offers a cavernous foyer leading into a large, pillared hall with terrazzo flooring and a coffered ceiling. A lit canopy arches across the former sanctuary, highlighting the building’s distinctive classical elements.
The exterior is defined by rough-textured masonry contrasted with vibrant red roof tiles and 25-foot picture windows. Being sold as-is condition. Offers Due by 2:00pm Monday 2/9/26. Email to listing agent. Proof of funds and contract required. LOI will not be accepted.
