59740 County Road 9, Newcomerstown, OH 43832
4 Beds • 3 Baths • 3,289 Sq Ft • 4.40 Acres
Historic Landmark Estate
Step back in time with this remarkable 1874 Italianate manor, originally built for the Honorable John Hardy and designed by noted architect Jacob Snyder. This three-story brick masterpiece has been thoughtfully restored to preserve its historic grandeur while offering modern comforts. Known throughout Newcomerstown as a true landmark property, the home features a 60-foot Belvedere tower, rare architectural details, and elegant craftsmanship reminiscent of European castles and cathedrals.
Restorations & Upgrades
Recent renovations have returned this estate to its former glory. Restored side porches, new corbels, soffits, and fascia highlight the careful attention to detail. The home itself received a new metal roof in 2021, while the barn and garage also feature newly installed metal roofs. Additional improvements include:
- Two new central A/C units
- New refrigerator and hammered copper sink
- Plaster walls skim-coated and freshly repainted
- Floors sanded and refinished throughout
- Lighted niches illuminating the grand stairwell
Every upgrade was completed with respect for the property’s history while enhancing everyday livability.
Architectural Beauty
This Italianate manor captures the eye with rounded windows, six fireplaces with marble mantels, and ornate ceilings that soar overhead. Hand-painted floors and decorative borders add character to many rooms. The home’s scale and artistry make it one of Ohio’s architectural treasures.
Spacious Interior
Offering over 3,200 square feet of living space, this residence balances historic detail with modern functionality.
Main Level:
- Grand foyer (5’ x 11’)
- Living room with fireplace (19’ x 18’)
- Formal dining room (16’ x 12’)
- Eat-in kitchen with wood floors (10’ x 25’)
- Sitting room (9’ x 14’)
- Full bath with ceramic tile (8’ x 12’)
- One bedroom (12’ x 19’) featuring a fireplace
Second Level:
- Three bedrooms (12’ x 20’, 17’ x 12’, 20’ x 18’), one with fireplace
- Primary bathroom (8’ x 12’) with wood floors
- Charming sunroom (10’ x 7’)
- Additional sitting/loft space (20’ x 8’)
Third Level:
- Loft with wood flooring (12’ x 12’)
Basement:
- Full, unfinished basement offering storage and expansion potential
Bedrooms & Bathrooms
- 4 spacious bedrooms with wood flooring, two featuring fireplaces
- 3 bathrooms (2 full, 1 half) with a mix of wood and ceramic tile flooring
- Main-level bedroom and bath provide convenience for multi-generational living
Outdoor Features
Set on 4.40 picturesque acres, this property is as captivating outside as it is inside. The grounds include:
- Barns and additional outbuildings
- Greenhouse frames and a framed outbuilding ready to finish
- Fenced pasture for horses or livestock
- Rare, mature trees planted throughout the property
- Scenic wooded views creating a private retreat
The property is registered with multiple parcels, providing additional flexibility for future use.
Property Details
- Style: Italianate / Victorian
- Construction: Solid brick exterior
- Roof: Durable metal (2021)
- Garage: 2-car detached with electricity
- Heating: Forced air, fireplaces, propane
- Cooling: Central air (2 new units)
- Water: Private well
- Sewer: Septic tank
Additional Information
- Total Structure Area: 3,289 sq. ft.
- Lot Size: 4.40 acres (multiple parcels included)
- Stories: 3 stories plus full basement
- Fireplaces: 6 (gas, wood-burning, and other)
- Security: Equipped with smoke and carbon monoxide detectors
A Rare Opportunity
This estate is more than a home—it’s a piece of Ohio history. With its distinguished architecture, careful restorations, and expansive grounds, the property offers the perfect blend of timeless beauty and modern updates. Ideal for history enthusiasts, equestrian lovers, or those seeking a one-of-a-kind country retreat, this home is a once-in-a-lifetime find.
👉 Listing Terms: Cash, Conventional, FHA, VA Loan
👉 Subdivision: Loveless Manor Sub
