Historic 1830 Laurel Dell House Brewster, New York For $799,900

385 Farm to Market Rd, Brewster, NY 10509

Now listed for sale at $799,900, Laurel Dell House is a truly unique historic home tucked away in the peaceful countryside of Brewster, New York. Set on 4.12 acres of beautifully landscaped grounds, this 1830s carriage house turned private residence offers the perfect balance between historic charm and modern comfort. With 2,358 square feet, 3 bedrooms, and 2 bathrooms, the property blends rustic design with updated convenience in a way that feels both timeless and welcoming.

Originally built in the 1830s and thoughtfully converted to a residence in the 1920s, the house retains many original architectural features. Inside, you’ll find exposed beams, vaulted ceilings, wide plank floors, and both a fireplace and wood-burning stove, all enhanced by natural light that pours in through oversized windows and skylights. A cozy sunroom, multiple living areas, and warm, inviting interiors create a relaxed, storybook feel throughout the home.

The kitchen adds to the property’s charm, with rustic wood cabinetry, open shelving, tile countertops, and garden views that complete its cottage-like appeal. Each bedroom offers a peaceful retreat, while recent updates—including a new furnace, generator, and electrical panel in 2018, and a new deck in 2022—ensure comfort and functionality year-round. Whether you’re gathering with family, working from home, or simply relaxing by the fire, Laurel Dell offers a flexible and serene environment.

Beyond the house, the real magic lies in the gardens and outdoor spaces. The grounds have been professionally designed and carefully cultivated to provide year-round color and interest. From the first daffodils of spring to the rich hues of autumn dahlias, something is always in bloom. A stream flows gently across the land, leading to a koi pond with a fountain that adds to the peaceful atmosphere. Brick patios, mature plantings, and well-planned borders invite quiet moments in nature, while soft landscape lighting creates a dreamy setting in the evenings.

This special estate for sale offers more than just a home—it’s a fully fenced, private haven with space to explore, grow, and recharge. The land stretches into wooded hills that border acres of preserved property owned by the Putnam County Land Trust, meaning the quiet surroundings are protected from future development. It’s the kind of setting that offers both privacy and lasting peace, a rare combination in today’s real estate market.

Additional features include a detached two-car garage with a workshop and upper-level loft, offering space for hobbies, creative work, or storage. This added flexibility opens up endless possibilities for buyers who want a studio, office, or guest space. Whether you’re an artist, gardener, remote worker, or simply someone looking to settle into a truly special place, this home for sale provides the space and setting to do it all.

Located just an hour and a half from New York City, this house is perfect for those seeking a weekend escape, a full-time residence surrounded by nature, or a manageable estate with character and soul. It combines the feeling of being far away from the city with the practicality of still being within reach of everyday conveniences.

Laurel Dell House is more than just a real estate listing—it’s a property that tells a story. With its long history, carefully planned gardens, and serene setting, it offers something rare in today’s market: a sense of calm and connection to the land. Buyers looking for charm, privacy, and natural beauty will find themselves right at home here.

If you’re searching for a house for sale in New York that offers space, character, and a deeply personal touch, Laurel Dell House is well worth a visit. To schedule a tour or learn more about this property, contact a trusted realtor familiar with historic homes and unique countryside estates.

Photos: