Great mountain escape! Historic luxury just one hour from NYC. $2,400,000.

Property Details & Main Features

Core Information

Address: 74 Tower Hill Loop E, Tuxedo Park, NY 10987
Price: $2,400,000
Status: Active Listing
Year Built: 1895 (Historic “Pell” Residence)
Living Area: 5,378 sq. ft.
Lot Size: 1.5 Acres

This historic landmark offers an incredible opportunity for anyone looking for a prestigious house for sale in a gated community. The sprawling 1.5-acre lot and 19th-century craftsmanship make this a standout choice for those seeking a legacy home.

Interior Architecture & Design

Bedrooms/Bathrooms: 5 Bedrooms, 6 Bathrooms (5 Full, 1 Half)
Living Spaces: Columned octagonal living room and a grand formal entry with a sweeping staircase.
Dining: Restored oak-paneled formal dining room.
Fireplaces: 6 masonry fireplaces throughout, including the primary suite and dining room.
Finishes: High ceilings, intricate millwork, original natural woodwork, and crown molding.

The interior layout balances historic grandeur with modern comfort, creating a truly unique residence for sale that is perfect for entertaining. From the octagonal living room to the soaring ceilings, every detail reflects the high-end architectural provenance of the late 1890s.

Lower Level & Specialty Rooms

Lower Level: Walk-out finished basement with versatile spaces.
Work & Play: Private office, recreation room, and a summer kitchen.
Wine Room: Climate-controlled wine cellar.
Porches: Three-season porch on the lower level and an elevated covered porch on the main level.

The versatility of the walk-out lower level and its luxury amenities like the wine cellar make this an exceptional property for sale for buyers who prioritize functional space. These additional rooms provide the perfect setting for a home office or guest quarters.

Exterior & Location

Views: Panoramic views of Tuxedo Lake and the surrounding mountains.
Exterior Materials: Finely laid brick, stone foundation, and a Dutch-gambrel roofline.
Landscape: Terraced lawns, stone garden pathways, and mature trees.
Parking: 1-car garage plus driveway parking for 3+ vehicles.
Community: Situated in historic, 24-hour-guarded Tuxedo Park, just one hour from Manhattan.

Set against the backdrop of Tuxedo Lake, this house for sale offers some of the most commanding vistas in the entire region. The secure gated community and proximity to New York City make it an ideal retreat for those seeking both privacy and accessibility.

From Zillow

An architectural tour-de-force with commanding siting, the former Herbert C. Pell residence stands among the most distinguished homes in Tuxedo Park – one of few positioned at high elevation with panoramic lake and mountain views to the South, East, and West. Designed in the late 1890s by architect William A. Bates, this masterpiece rises from a monolithic, native stone foundation, its structure appearing to emerge naturally from the hillside as a testament to engineering and artistry.

Finely laid brick and hand-crafted millwork form an exterior of remarkable beauty and enduring craftsmanship. The facade’s Neoclassical, Georgian, Queene Anne and Greek Revival details along with the Dutch-gambrel rooflines, create a residence of timeless appeal in the classic Tuxedo Park vernacular. Inside, the home is balanced between grandeur and comfort, making it as ideal for entertaining on a grand scale as it is for refined daily living.

A formal entry and sweeping staircase introduce high-ceilinged rooms filled with natural light and long views over Tuxedo Lake. A columned octagonal living room with intricate millwork and large windows anchor the formal spaces, while the restored oak-paneled dining room features a wood-burning fireplace and generous scale for gatherings both intimate and large. Both rooms open to an elevated, covered porch that extends the living area outside to embrace breathtaking vistas with Tuxedo Lake shimmering below, under sunrise and sunset.

Throughout the home, six distinctive fireplaces punctuate the interiors with warmth and architectural interest. Rounding out the main level are the kitchen and the richly appointed library with bar shelving, built-in book shelving, and oversized windows. The second floor offers five spacious bedrooms, some with striking lake or mountain views, fireplaces and en-suite baths. The primary suite offers exceptional views, fireplace, dressing room, walk-in-closet and ensuite bath. The partially renovated top floor invites customization as studios, playroom, exercise rooms, or guest suite, here also with outstanding scenic views.

A walk-out lower level enhances versatility with a private office, summer kitchen, recreation room, full bath, three-season porch, and a climate-controlled wine room. Set on approximately 1.5 acres, the property features terraced lawns, and stone garden pathways. Mature trees, native plantings, and the elevated topography ensure privacy and scenic beauty in every season. Perfectly situated in the heart of historic, 24-hour-guarded Tuxedo Park – just about one hour from New York City – this landmark residence embodies the community’s architectural legacy and lakeside lifestyle, offering a rare combination of premium location, architectural provenance and comfortable, inspired living.