Full of Charm! Classic Victorian Home For $243,500 In Waverly, New York!

19 Ithaca St, Waverly, NY 14892

$243,500 | 2,942 Sq. Ft. | 4 Beds | 3 Baths

19 Ithaca Street in Waverly, New York represents a quintessential opportunity for anyone who dreams of owning a classic Victorian home full of charm, craftsmanship, and warmth. Listed at $243,500, this house for sale is a rare find in today’s real estate market, where so many properties feel standardized or overly modernized. Instead, this home offers something more meaningful: character that has been preserved, history that can still be felt, and a sense of place that invites imagination. With four bedrooms, three bathrooms, and nearly 3,000 square feet of living space, the property is large enough to support a variety of lifestyles while still maintaining the intimacy and grace that define Victorian architecture.

The approach to the house sets the tone immediately. A wide set of stairs leads up to a generous and welcoming front porch that wraps halfway around the home. In many ways, this porch is one of the most compelling features buyers will notice, because it embodies what so many people want but rarely find in modern construction: a space designed for simply being. The feeling is graceful, relaxed, and reminiscent of days when homes were gathering places, not just structures. Comfy chairs, soft lighting, potted flowers, and the gentle movement of the breeze would easily make this porch a morning haven or a perfect spot to unwind at sunset. For anyone who values the simple luxury of enjoying a favorite beverage while watching the neighborhood change with the seasons, this front porch alone makes the home worth a closer look.

Inside, the sense of charm continues. The woodwork is striking, representing a level of craftsmanship that is rarely replicated in contemporary real estate. Hardwood floors flow throughout the main level, tying each room together with a sense of continuity and warmth. While many modern homes try to recreate the look of original materials using newer products, the authenticity here is unmistakable. The details—trim work, mouldings, door frames—reflect a time when builders and artisans poured heart and skill into every inch of a house. Walking through the entryway into the first rooms, you begin to notice how effortlessly the spaces connect. Rather than the abrupt transitions you might find in homes that have been renovated without regard for original layout, this home maintains its natural and intentional flow.

Each room has its own personality, but all share that Victorian hallmark of thoughtful design and quiet elegance. The living areas offer plenty of space for comfortable furniture arrangements without losing the cozy ambiance that makes old homes so beloved. In every direction, small architectural touches—interesting accents, unexpected nooks, minor curves in the woodwork, window placements that let in soft natural light—add visual interest and emotional warmth. These are the kinds of details that help people feel at home, not just housed.

The dining room is ideal for anyone who enjoys hosting friends or family. Whether it’s a weekly dinner, a holiday gathering, or a casual weekend brunch, the atmosphere enhances any meal. The high ceilings, natural light, and hardwood floors create an environment that feels both elegant and unfussy. This is not a home trying to impress through sleek minimalism; it impresses by being exactly what it is—a lovingly maintained Victorian with history, character, and soul.

The kitchen sits toward the back of the home and leads out to a private little patio that acts as a charming bonus space. This area is perfect for morning coffee or quiet evenings enjoying fresh air among blooming flowers and bushes that surround the yard. The outdoor environment is intimate without feeling cramped, and because the landscaping is already established, the next owner can enjoy mature plantings that return year after year. Many homes for sale advertise outdoor potential but offer little more than grass. Here, the landscaping plays an important role in the overall feel of the property. It supports the Victorian character and creates an appealing backdrop to daily life.

Moving upstairs, the second level contains nice-sized bedrooms, each filled with natural light. These rooms feel inviting and peaceful, making them ideal for family members, guests, creative spaces, or home offices. The full bathroom on this level enhances convenience and supports a variety of living arrangements. The bedrooms maintain the same charming details found throughout the home, continuing the visual consistency that makes older homes feel cohesive and thoughtfully designed.

The third level of the house holds the primary bedroom suite, which adds another level of versatility and appeal. This private retreat is complemented by its own full bathroom and an additional sitting area or dressing room. The extra space creates a sense of luxury without being ostentatious. It also allows the homeowner to personalize the suite to their liking—an office nook, a reading space, a dressing area, or even a meditative corner. The layout feels intentional and functional, giving the top floor a cozy separation from the rest of the home. In real estate, primary suites with distinct extras like dressing rooms or sitting areas often become focal points for buyers, especially those who appreciate the blend of charm and practical living. This upper-floor haven strikes that perfect balance.

One of the strengths of this home is its adaptability. With nearly 2,942 square feet, the house offers more room than many modern constructions in this price range, and much of the layout lends itself to flexible living. Whether the homeowner works remotely, needs space for hobbies, prefers guest accommodations, or simply wants room to grow, the floor plan accommodates. The blend of preserved Victorian character and modern updates creates a home that feels timeless rather than dated.

While the interior carries the weight of history and craftsmanship, the mechanical and structural updates ensure comfort and safety. The sellers have updated the plumbing, electrical systems, and heating, which significantly boosts long-term value. Older homes can sometimes intimidate buyers who worry about outdated systems or expensive repairs. However, the work done here allows the next owner to enjoy the aesthetic benefits of a historic home without inheriting major functional issues. This is a selling point that any realtor would emphasize, because it positions the home not only as beautiful but also as reliable and practical for everyday living.

Outside, the backyard offers more space for relaxation, gardening, or entertaining. Between the patio and the blooming landscaping, the area feels like an extension of the indoor living spaces—private, serene, and full of potential. The driveway on the side of the home accommodates one car, but could be extended if the next homeowner wishes. In many real estate markets, parking can be a challenge, so the option to lengthen the driveway adds flexibility and value.

The neighborhood itself enhances the property’s attractiveness. Waverly, New York, is a community with warmth and character, offering a blend of small-town comfort and accessibility to nearby amenities. For buyers seeking a scenic setting without sacrificing convenience, this location is ideal. Tree-lined streets, friendly neighbors, and a sense of historic charm define the area, making it a place where homeowners feel connected not only to their house but to the surrounding community.

This home is also ideal for anyone who appreciates Victorian architecture but wants a move-in-ready option instead of a major renovation project. Many Victorian homes on the market need extensive restoration efforts, both interior and exterior. But the sellers of 19 Ithaca Street have maintained the home beautifully, making sure essential updates were completed while leaving the historic charm intact. This thoughtful stewardship ensures that the house remains compelling to modern buyers without losing the features that make it so special.

In the real estate world, character homes are often described using familiar phrases—warm, inviting, charming—but this home genuinely earns all of those descriptions. When a buyer steps inside, they will immediately recognize the intangible quality that separates historic homes from contemporary builds. It is a feeling of connection, of story, of possibility. And as buyers look for houses listed for sale that offer more than square footage and neutral paint, this kind of authenticity becomes increasingly treasured.

Additionally, the sellers’ motivation adds another layer of opportunity for buyers. A motivated seller often means smoother negotiations, quicker timelines, and greater flexibility during the sale process. Whether a buyer is entering the real estate market for the first time or seeking a distinctive home with long-term potential, this property stands out as a smart and emotionally appealing choice.

Every corner of the home reinforces the idea that Victorian architecture remains timeless. It is not simply old; it is enduring. The wraparound porch encourages slower mornings and thoughtful evenings. The hardwood floors reflect decades of footsteps and stories, yet still shine beautifully. The staircases, moldings, and detailed woodwork remind us that homes were once built with artistry and pride. Even the sunlight filtering through the windows seems to carry history with it.

A house like this does not just offer shelter; it provides atmosphere. It shapes the experiences of the people who live within its walls. Whether it becomes the setting for family gatherings, the inspiration for creative pursuits, or a peaceful retreat from the busyness of life, it offers room for both memory and imagination. And because the mechanical systems have been updated, it manages to offer all this charm without sacrificing comfort.

From a practical standpoint, the size of the home makes it appealing for those who need flexibility. Multi-level living accommodates households with varying needs, whether large families, multi-generational living, or homeowners who need space for work and projects. The combination of historical character and updated functionality presents a powerful mix—a home that feels both nostalgic and current.

Real estate trends often shift, but homes with enduring style and emotional impact consistently attract buyers. This house for sale at 19 Ithaca Street stands firmly in that category. It is priced competitively, offers substantial square footage, includes modern improvements, features iconic Victorian character, and sits in a welcoming community. It is listed at a level that makes ownership accessible while still delivering the architectural richness of a far more expensive home.

For those searching for a home that feels meaningful rather than generic, this house offers the best of both worlds. It invites the next owner not just to live within its walls, but to become part of its story—one chapter in a narrative stretching back to 1900s craftsmanship and forward into the future. In the realm of real estate, where so many choices can feel similar, this home stands apart. It is an opportunity to embrace history, comfort, beauty, and potential in one thoughtful and well-loved property.

Photos: