If you have a soft spot for historic homes that tell a story, you are going to fall in love with this beautiful property in Cherry Valley. It is an Italianate-style house built in 1850, and it still has all that wonderful charm that makes old buildings so special.
Quick Property Details
- Address: 21 Lancaster St, Cherry Valley, NY 13320
- Price: $275,000
- Bedrooms: 5
- Bathrooms: 3 Full Baths
- Square Feet: 3,382 sq ft
- Lot Size: 0.27 Acres
- Key Features: Historic Italianate design, original wood floors, wrap-around porch, grand staircase, carriage barn, and a cupola.
A Grand Welcome Home
From the moment you pull up to the curb, this house grabs your attention. It has a classic wrap-around front porch that is just perfect for sitting outside with a cup of coffee on a quiet morning. The front entrance is just as impressive, featuring a large double door that leads you into a home full of history.
Once you step inside, the first thing you will notice is the grand staircase. It feels like something out of a movie. The living room and dining room are filled with natural light thanks to the large French windows. These rooms feel open and airy, but they still have that cozy, old-world feel with beautiful hardwood floors underfoot.
Plenty of Space to Grow
This house is quite large, offering over 3,300 square feet of living space. With five bedrooms and three full bathrooms, there is plenty of room for a big family or for hosting friends. The kitchen is an eat-in style, making it the heart of the home where everyone can gather for meals. There is even a dedicated office space for those who work from home.
One of my favorite parts of the house is the upstairs sitting area. It sits right at the top of the stairs and feels like a secret little nook for reading or relaxing. If you need even more room, the attic is huge and unfinished. It features a charming cupola that lets in light, and you could easily turn this space into a massive master suite or a creative studio.
Hidden Gems and Extra Features
For those who love projects or need storage, this property has a lot to offer. There is a full basement with a workshop and a den, which is great for hobbies. Outside, you will find a rear deck for summer BBQs and a detached carriage barn. This barn is a rare find and provides a lot of extra space for a garage or storage.
Even though the house is 175 years old, it has been updated to be comfortable. It features a 12-zone heating system, which is amazing for keeping the house warm in the winter without wasting energy. This allows you to heat only the rooms you are using, which is a big plus for a home this size.
Living in Cherry Valley
The location is just as lovely as the house itself. You are only a short walk away from the local shops and restaurants in the village of Cherry Valley. It is a peaceful, friendly area that feels tucked away from the busy world, yet it is an easy drive to places like Cooperstown or Albany.
If you appreciate the craftsmanship of the past and want a home with real character, 21 Lancaster Street is a dream come true. It is a rare chance to own a piece of history that is ready for its next chapter. Whether you want a large family home or even a bed and breakfast, this house has the bones and the beauty to make it happen.
